| Singles competition |
| 1. Jansen Hein (MESSM) vs. Robert Brown (LYCOMTEN) no result |
| 2. Luke Hostetter (MESSM) vs. Alex Beattie (LYCOMTEN) no result |
| 3. Jason Mifsud (LYCOMTEN) def. Andrew Wismer (MESSM) 7-5, 7-5 |
| 4. David Brown (LYCOMTEN) def. Kyle Keen (MESSM) 6-3, 6-4 |
| 5. Phillip Shannon (LYCOMTEN) def. Adam Sheir (MESSM) 6-3, 6-3 |
| 6. Cody Heffner (LYCOMTEN) def. Luke Sisson (MESSM) 6-0, 6-3 |
| Doubles competition |
| 1. Jansen Hein/Luke Hostetter (MESSM) def. Alex Beattie/Jason Mifsud (LYCOMTEN) 8-0 |
| 2. David Brown/Robert Brown (LYCOMTEN) def. Andrew Wismer/Kyle Keen (MESSM) 8-0 |
| 3. Adam Sheir/Luke Sisson (MESSM) def. Phillip Shannon/Cody Heffner (LYCOMTEN) 8-5 |
| Match Notes |
| No. 3 Messiah College 8-11 |
| No. 2 Lycoming College 9-2 |
| Commonwealth Conference semifinals |
| Winner faces victor of No. 1 Elizabethtown/No. 4 Lebanon Valley College |
| Finals held at highest remaining seed on Saturday, May 8 |